Choosing your baby’s first earrings shouldn’t be stressful. Below we break down the safest metals, the best earring backs for infants and toddlers, and exactly what to avoid - plus our hypoallergenic, nickel-free picks trusted by parents of newborns and toddlers. Every order ships fast and free.
We enforce strict safety testing on an ongoing basis. Our products comply with ASTM F 2923-11 (Standard Specification for Consumer Product Safety for Children’s Jewelry)
All our jewelry is 100% hypoallergenic and free of nickel, lead, and other dangerous metals. We are proud to manufacture the safest children’s jewelry available.
Every order ships fast & free WORLDWIDE with orders of $25. Shop confidently with our industry best 90 day warranty and NO HASSLE returns!
The earring back matters even more than the design when it comes to a baby. The right back stays put, won’t poke a tiny earlobe, and can’t be pulled out by curious fingers. Here’s how the common options compare for infants and toddlers.
| Back type | How it works | Best for babies? |
|---|---|---|
| Safety screw-back | Threaded post and back screw together and lock, so they only come off intentionally. | Best choice. Most secure - ideal for active babies and toddlers and for sleeping. |
| Flat / safety push-back | A flat, rounded back that pushes on snugly and sits flush against the lobe. | Good. Comfortable and low-profile, slightly less secure than a screw-back. |
| Standard butterfly back | The familiar friction back that pinches onto the post. | Not recommended for babies - works loose easily and the open prongs can poke. |
Want the full breakdown of which styles actually stay in on an active child? Read our companion guide: kids earrings that won’t fall out.
“Hypoallergenic” only means something if the metal underneath is genuinely safe. For baby earrings, stick to nickel-free precious metals and avoid cheap mystery alloys.
| Metal | Why it’s used | Notes for babies |
|---|---|---|
| 14k gold | Naturally hypoallergenic, durable, won’t tarnish. | Excellent. A classic safe choice for first earrings. ISJ uses ethically sourced 14k. |
| Sterling silver (925) | Nickel-free, affordable, on-trend designs. | Excellent and budget-friendly - one of the safest everyday metals for infants and toddlers. |
| Surgical / stainless steel | Common in starter studs; inexpensive. | Generally fine, but grades vary - some contain trace nickel. Confirm it’s nickel-free. |
| Titanium | Inert and lightweight. | Safe, but limited designs and pricier for small sizes. |
| Avoid: nickel, cheap alloys, plated costume metal | - | Leading cause of reactions and irritation in children. Skip anything that doesn’t state its metal. |
Every InSeason Jewelry piece is 100% nickel-free and lead-free and tested to ASTM F2923-11, the U.S. safety standard for children’s jewelry.
Ideal for the baby on the go, safety screw back earrings are the ideal solution, offering comfort and safety, while ensuring no more lost earring backs!
Hypoallergenic 14k gold or sterling silver studs with a safety screw-back or flat push-back. These stay secure, sit flush against the lobe, and are nickel-free so they’re gentle on new piercings and sensitive skin.
Yes. Genuine 925 sterling silver is naturally nickel-free and is considered one of the safest, most comfortable metals for infants and toddlers.
A safety screw-back. The post and back thread together and lock, so the earring can’t fall out or be pulled out - the rounded, flat back also protects the earlobe.
Many pediatricians say any time after the first round of vaccinations (around 2-3 months), but timing is a personal choice - ask your pediatrician. Whenever you do it, start with hypoallergenic, nickel-free studs.
InSeason Jewelry specializes in hypoallergenic, nickel-free earrings designed specifically for babies and kids, with safety screw-backs and free worldwide shipping. Shop baby earrings.
What can we say, people love us! And we love them back
Kelly finds the perfect gifts for her kids! Her son loves his personalized dog tag necklace, while her daughter adores her heart necklace from In Season Jewelry.
Riley discovers the perfect heart-shaped screw-back earrings from In Season Jewelry! Safe, hypoallergenic, and stylish, perfect for her!
Hailey and her mom Kate review our adorable Hypoallergenic Flower Earrings and stunning CZ Star Necklace from In Season Jewelry! Stylish and safe for sensitive skin!
